Sundance Review: Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes - Flixist

Sundance Review: Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes

9:30 AM on 01.25.2013

Blank page

Throughout the entirety of Sundance, Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes was the only movie I didn't take any notes on. I guess this is what is implied by "noteworthy," and Emanuel is not. For the life of me, I couldn't pick up my pencil and write anything of note, because something of note would have to exist in the first place.

Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes
Director: Francesca Gregorini
Rating: NR
Country: USA
Release Date: January 18, 2013 (Sundance Film Festival)

Emanuel is not likely to escape comparisons to Lars and the Real Girl (in which a man keeps a blowup doll for a girlfriend, insisting it's real even as others point out it's not) as it is a more dramatic take on Lars' plot. A few (non-notable) alterations, take out charmer Ryan Gosling, and you have a very similar film that is as dull and twice as slow.

Instead of a man in love with a blowup doll, Emanuel is centered around middle-aged "mom" Linda (Jessica Biel) with a doll for a daughter. The titular character (played well by Skins' Kaya Scodelario) is a snotty, young girl with clever lines delivered to whoever will listen, mostly her father, step-mom, co-worker, and some boy on the bus she sees everyday. With nothing better to do than be a jerk and dance around to French pop, she picks-up a new job as Linda's baby sitter. After some puzzling scenes that heighten tension around this mysterious baby that is never witnessed, Emanuel finally gets to hold this porcelain doll. Instead of notifying someone, she plays along and embraces Linda's maladjusted reality.

Like Lars and the Real Girl, Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes stumbles around the same jokes and obstacles for the remainder of the film until the rote emotional climax. Emanuel is a joyless film with a dull finale, outside a neat dream sequence near the end that depicts Emanuel swimming in her house. Yes, the baby isn't real and Linda thinks it is. I'm not sure if that's funny the first time, but it's definitely not funny the fifth or seventh. Maybe Emanuel and Linda unloading their troubled pasts would be cathartic if it weren't so obvious from the start or so cliche when it occurs.

This review too is un-noteworthy. What can I say about a film that doesn't stir me one way or another? I look at my notebook that reads: "Emanuel ... Lars and the Real Girl." The rest of the page is empty. And, so it is with the film.


Emanuel and the Truth About Fishes - Reviewed by Allistair Pinsof

Bad. While very few people may find this film worthwhile, the vast majority will want to skip it altogether. Movies like this have very little redeeming value.

Get comment replies by email.     settings

Unsavory comments? Please report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our comment moderators

Can't see comments? Anti-virus apps like Avast or some browser extensions can cause this. Easy fix: Add   [*]   to your security software's whitelist.

Allistair Pinsof

This blog submitted to our editor via our Community Blogs, and then it made it to the home page! You can follow community members and vote up their blogs - support each other so we can promote a more diverse and deep content mix on our home page.


Allistair Pinsof

First trailer for Barely Lethal sure is lethal

First trailer for Black Mass starring Johnny Depp

First trailer for Takashi Miike's Yakuza Apocalypse

Ads on Flixist may be purchased from:

Please contact Crave Online, thanks!



The All-American Avengers

by Jackson Tyler


Snaxist: Kellogg's Avengers: Age of Ultron Cereal

by Nick Valdez


Comic Book Movies 101: Avengers: Age of Ultron

by Matt Liparota


Will Darth Vader return in Star Wars: The Force Awakens?

by Matt Liparota


Why It Sucks To Go To The Movies In London

by Jackson Tyler


Flixist Discusses: Neill Blomkamp

by Jackson Tyler


FlixList: The Top 10 Movie Robots

by Nick Valdez


FlixList: Ten NEW Cartoons that Deserve Movies

by John-Charles Holmes


6 things we want from Neill Blomkamp's Alien project

by Per Morten Mjolkeraaen


Movies That Changed Us: Super

by Jackson Tyler

Back to Top