After the Credits: The Academy Award Gravity didn't deserve to win


Gravity looks amazing, but Emmanuel Lubezki got too much credit

I have nothing but respect for Emmanuel Lubezki. He's an excellent cinematographer who has composed some spectacular shots in his time. But I also think that his Oscar win Sunday night was misguided. Gravity, while perhaps the technical pinnacle of films he's worked on, is not the pinnacle of his own work. Watch any behind the scenes on Gravity (this is the one referred to in the video above) and you will see that while the actual camera movements generally corresponded with a real camera (and as such, the fascinating opening shot can be mostly credited to him), what went into that Arri Alexa bear little resemblance to the spectacular images that were projected onto screens.

Like Life of Pi's win last year, this represents an unfortunate trend, one that gets into the heart of what cinematography is, and it may be that some disagree with my somewhat more naturalistic view of cinematography, but that's what debate is for. If you agree, disagree, or whatever, let me know. I'd love to talk about it. Also, check out the other videos on our YouTube page and subscribe and do all that good stuff. 

You are logged out. Login | Sign up



Alec Kubas-Meyer
Alec Kubas-MeyerReviews & Features Editor   gamer profile

Alec Kubas-Meyer signed up for Flixist in May of 2011 as a news writer, and he never intended to write a single review. Funny, then, that he is now the site's Reviews (and Features) Editor. After... more + disclosures



Also on Flixist: Gravity   (12)   From our database:

  • Five movies you love that aren't as good as Mad Max: Fury Road - Alec Kubas-Meyer
  • Alfonso Cuarón's Forsaken is a prequel of sorts to Gravity - Matthew Razak
  • After the Credits: The Academy Award Gravity didn't deserve to win - Alec Kubas-Meyer
  • Here are you 2014 Oscar winners - Matthew Razak
  • The best damn Oscar predictions around: 2014 edition - Matthew Razak
  • Gravity re-releasing in theaters this weekend - Matthew Razak
  • You can download all these rad screenplays for no money! - Mike Cosimano
  • FlixList: The Ten Best Trailers of 2013 - Nick Valdez
  • Your 2014 Golden Globe nominations are here - Matthew Razak
  • More related stories
    Filed under... #After the Credits #Alfonso Cuarón #best cinematography #Best Visual Effects #cinematography #Top Stories #video #Visual Effects



    You're not expected to always agree, but do please keep cool and never make it personal. Report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community team. Also, on the right side of a comment you can flag nasty comments anonymously (we ban users dishing bad karma). For everything else, contact us!