Has Superman lost his soul?


We answer The (Movie) Question!

Critically, the reception to Zack Snyder's Man of Steel has been all over the place. Although the Rotten Tomatoes consensus says that it is "mostly successful" (something corroborated by our review), it is nonetheless considered Rotten, with only 55% of the 228 critics giving it positive marks. This debate has played out in dozens of essays across the internet, many of them focused on the bleakness of this new world as well as the implications of the film's bombastic final act.

That variety of opinion is as true here at Flixist, so we decided to focus this week's The (Movie) Question on it. But this isn't just about whether or not the film is good, because that would be boring. No, we're looking at the character of Superman and what's become of him. Beneath all of the grit and violence, is this still the same character or have cynicism and "realism" robbed him of his humanity?

I should note that there are very minor spoilers in this week's video. Nick's section (which is last) speaks the most directly about events later in the film, while the rest allude to things rather than discuss them outright. It's somewhat difficult to really have this conversation without spoilers, but we did a decent job I think. The Man of Steel Flixist Movie Club has been pushed back to next week, and I'm sure that this discussion will continue there and everywhere until something else comes along.

If you've got an opinion, please put it to the comments. I'm sure everyone on the video (and those who aren't) have lots more to say. If you've seen the film, I'm sure you do too.

You are logged out. Login | Sign up



Alec Kubas-Meyer
Alec Kubas-MeyerReviews & Features Editor   gamer profile

Alec Kubas-Meyer signed up for Flixist in May of 2011 as a news writer, and he never intended to write a single review. Funny, then, that he is now the site's Reviews (and Features) Editor. After... more + disclosures



Also on Flixist: Man of Steel   (18)   From our database:

  • Johns: 'Justice League' will address 'BvS' criticisms - Matt Liparota
  • Warner Bros moving forward with Man of Steel sequel - Nick Valdez
  • Angry nerds start petition to fire Zack Snyder from future DC movies - Hubert Vigilla
  • New Releases, week of 11/16/13: Turbo Man Edition - Nick Valdez
  • Flix for Short: Superman's 75th Anniversary Short - Nick Valdez
  • Superman 75th short screened at NYCC - Matthew Razak
  • Snyder offers up a BS excuse for the end of Man of Steel - Matthew Razak
  • Box Office Numbers: Wossamotta U - Hubert Vigilla
  • Max Landis also has opinions about Man of Steel - Nick Valdez
  • More related stories
    Filed under... #Flixist #superman #The (Movie) Question #Top Stories #video



    You're not expected to always agree, but do please keep cool and never make it personal. Report harassment, spam, and hate speech to our community team. Also, on the right side of a comment you can flag nasty comments anonymously (we ban users dishing bad karma). For everything else, contact us!