Movie Debate to the Death! Best J.J. Abrams film?


In the last debate I gave everyone time to watch the new Pirates of the Caribbean film, and now that we’ve all seen On Stranger Tides — or chosen not to — the votes are final. I expected one of the four films to win by landslide, but hoped a few closet sequel fans would come out of the shadows. There were a few fans, but none were willing to rank any higher than the first film, which resulted in a complete shut-out win for The Curse of the Black Pearl, which received all 13 votes that were cast.

This week I’m willing to do something I usually don’t allow. Instead of just picking from which films someone wrote or directed, I’m also going to let everyone include the movies J.J. Abrams was a producer for when picking which of his films is your favorite. If it’s a movie, and J.J. Abrams touched it, then it counts!

Cast your vote in the comments below, discuss it with other community members, and check back next week to see which film won!